If you have a passion for coffee like we do, you won’t settle for a fake “coffee-like” flavouring made with cheap imitation coffee; you want the real thing. We tried as many different kinds of coffee ice cream as our belts would allow us to in order to provide you with an honest opinion on which kinds of coffee ice cream we think are the best. This was done solely for your benefit. These reviews are a compilation of our top picks to assist you in selecting the best coffee ice cream to satisfy both your desire for sweets and your need for coffee.
A Quick Comparison of Our Favorites
The 6 Best Coffee Ice Cream – Reviews 2023
1. Ben & Jerry’s Vermont’s Finest Ice Cream – Best Overall
Ben & Jerry’s has a knack for coming up with attention-grabbing names for their ice cream flavours, and “Coffee, Coffee BuzzBuzzBuzz!” was one of the names that particularly stood out to us. The flavour of the ice cream, which lives up to its moniker by packing a potent dose of coffee flavour, is what sets it apart from other varieties of coffee ice cream. Throughout these evaluations, we have placed a premium on genuine, mouthwatering coffee flavour above all else, and the fact that “Coffee, Coffee BuzzBuzzBuzz!” boasts a coffee flavour that lives up to that standard places it at the top of our list of recommended products.
The ice cream itself lives up to the exceptional quality that has become synonymous with Ben & Jerry’s products. Because they don’t skimp on the fudge chunks, both chocolate and coffee lovers will be able to put their spoons down feeling satisfied. Your best bet is to make your purchase online because discovering such a variety in physical stores may prove to be challenging at times. By a significant margin, this was the best ice cream that we tried. The flavour is spot on for us in terms of the harmony between the coffee and the ice cream, and the chocolate chunks are a welcome addition.
Pros
- Authentic coffee taste
- Plentiful fudge chunks
- Good value
- Deliciously smooth
Cons
- Difficult to find in stores
2. Haagen Dazs Coffee Ice Cream – Best Value
The Haagen-Dazs Coffee ice cream takes the number two spot on our list. Coffee ice cream is made in the same fashion as other Haagen-Dazs ice creams, which are characterised by their high quality and their use of straightforward ingredients. In contrast to most other flavoured ice creams, this one does not contain any artificial flavours or additives of any kind.
If you like your coffee ice cream with less of a punch, you might like this one because the coffee flavour is noticeable without being overpowering. On the other hand, if you desire a robust coffee taste that is brought to the forefront, you could find that you enjoy another alternative more. This ice cream does not include any additional ingredients, such as chocolate chips, chunks, or any other toppings of any kind. We’re fans of the stripped-down approach, but if you’re hoping for a lot of bells and whistles, you may be disappointed.
Overall, the Haagen-Dazs Coffee ice cream has a texture that is typical for the brand and consists of smoothness and creaminess, with a touch of coffee flavouring on the side. The coffee taste isn’t overpowering, which is why this one isn’t in the number one spot on our list, but considering how cheap it is, it’s easily the greatest coffee ice cream option out there.
Pros
- Very affordable
- Creamy and smooth
- All-natural ingredients
- Genuine coffee flavor
3. Sweetie Coffee Ice Creams – Premium Choice
On the very other end of the flavour range, we have ice creams called Sweetie Coffee. Sweetie has positioned itself as a luxury brand, with the primary emphasis being on delivering all of the deliciousness of ice cream while minimising the amount of sugar that is present in each serving. The same can be said about their coffee selection. This ice cream has a fantastic flavour overall, but the coffee flavour is very delicious. Because we couldn’t believe that an ice cream with less sugar could taste this amazing, we examined the label many times to be sure we weren’t mistaken.
Sweetie makes up for the low amount of sugar with allulose, which is not a problem for us but is something that you should be aware of. Allulose is a natural sweetener that does not have any of the negative side effects that are associated with sucralose or aspartame.
Because Sweetie is not inexpensive, you will be required to pay an exorbitant price in order to obtain this level of quality and nutrition. If you are interested in indulging in a delectable coffee dessert, but are concerned about the amount of sugar and fat that you consume, we believe that you should consider spending the extra money.
Pros
- Delicious coffee flavor
- Satisfies cravings
- Low fat and sugar
Cons
- Very expensive
- Contains sugar alcohol
4. Rebel Coffee Ice Cream
An intriguing strategy is utilised by Rebel Coffee Ice Cream in the production of their low carb and low sugar ice cream. They use sugar alcohol in the production of their ice cream, which contributes to the product’s remarkable lack of sugar. The fact that they use their low-carb ice cream recipe as an opportunity to pack it full of chocolate chips without going overboard on the sugar budget is an intriguing aspect of their approach. People who follow low-carb diets often find it difficult to enjoy a satisfying dessert due to the restrictions placed on sugar intake; therefore, this ice cream is an excellent option for people who follow diets that limit their sugar intake.
We are huge fans of the combination of coffee and chocolate, especially when it comes to an ice cream that is suitable for keto and diabetic diets, but we weren’t as crazy about the texture. We are under the impression that the low-carb recipe may have contributed in some way to the peculiar mouthfeel. It wasn’t so bad that it rendered it inedible, so if you’re more concerned with the positive effects on your health, it might be worthwhile for you to try it anyway. On the other hand, if you are more concerned about your health, you should go with Sweetie. The quality of the Rebel coffee ice cream is not quite on par with that of Sweetie’s, but it is still acceptable and costs less.
Pros
- Satisfying coffee flavor
- Keto and diabetic friendly
- Chocolate chips add a nice crunch
Cons
- Off-putting texture
- Slightly expensive
5. New Orleans Ice Cream Company
On our list, the ice cream with the Coffee & Chicory flavour from New Orleans Ice Cream Company stands out as the most distinctively flavoured option. Give this one a shot if you want to literally kick your coffee ice cream up a notch, and it will do just that. The use of chicory in coffee is a long-standing custom in New Orleans, and the resulting beverage tastes unlike any other kind of coffee. The unusual taste combination works surprisingly well when it’s used in ice cream as well. The chicory in this ice cream imparts a flavour that is both nutty and gently spicy, creating an experience that is not only quite distinctive but also incredibly delicious.
Although it is on the pricier end of things, you are getting something that is really unique and cannot be found anywhere else. Unfortunately, we do not believe that the taste is suitable for everyone, therefore you should be aware that it is possible that it will not be suitable for you. This is not the best option to go with if you are looking for an ice cream with a simple coffee taste. Those with exploratory tastes who are searching for something new to try that maintains a flavour profile that is mostly coffee will find this to be an excellent option.
Pros
- Very unorthodox flavor
- Real coffee taste
- Creamy and smooth
Cons
- Chicory flavor is not for everyone
- A bit expensive
6. Mr. Green Tea Cold Brew Coffee Ice Cream
Ice cream made from cold brew coffee is next on our list, and it’s made by Mr. Green Tea. This flavour of ice cream does not include any green tea, despite the fact that the brand name suggests otherwise; nevertheless, there is another variety that does contain green tea. The Cold Brew coffee flavour is an ice cream with coffee flavouring, and it also contains espresso beans that have been coated in chocolate. The coffee beans are the main attractions of this production. They give the mixture a pleasing crunch in addition to contributing even more coffee taste, which is ultimately what pushed this ice cream to the top of our ranking.
Instead than relying significantly on the ice cream itself to offer the flavour, the ice cream relies heavily on the espresso beans to supply the taste. This seems to largely taste like normal ice cream with espresso beans, which isn’t necessarily a terrible thing, but it may not be what you’re hoping for. Our sense is that this is how it tastes.
Be advised that since this ice cream has both full fat and full sugar, it is not appropriate for certain diets and you should not consume it if you are following one of such programmes. On the other hand, if you are looking for a sumptuous coffee dessert, this won’t let you down.
Pros
- Chocolate covered espresso beans are a nice touch
- Very creamy
- No artificial additives
Cons
- Ice cream flavor is mild
- Very expensive
Buyer’s Guide
After you’ve had the chance to go over our shortlist, we’d like to go over a few of the specifics that are important to keep in mind while shopping for coffee ice cream. Because flavour is, in the end, a matter of individual choice, we will concentrate mostly on objective aspects such as the ingredients, the price, and the health implications.
- The Coffee
When purchasing coffee ice cream, the origin of the coffee taste is the single most significant factor to take into consideration. You should, as a general rule, stay away from ice cream that has flavours added in artificially. A coffee flavoured with artificial flavouring is likely to have an unpleasant aftertaste, may cause headaches in some individuals, and will almost never taste like genuine coffee. The ice cream that is combined with genuine coffee beans is by far our top choice since it imparts a more authentic coffee taste. Not only does this provide you the authentic flavour of coffee, which is what the vast majority of people are searching for, but it also gives you the piece of mind that comes with knowing that you are not putting any potentially hazardous chemicals into your body.
Checking the label is the quickest and simplest method to determine whether or not you are receiving authentic coffee ice cream. The ingredients will include a full disclosure of any and all additives, including synthetic flavours and sweeteners.
- Your Diet
We get it. You are making an effort to consume a diet that is nutritious and well-balanced, therefore ice cream has no place in your refrigerator at this point. Instead of completely eliminating sweets and snacks from your diet, one of the most effective strategies for sticking to a diet is to indulge in them occasionally and in moderation. Ice cream is an extremely calorically rich meal that is also high in fat and contains more sugar than the majority of people need in a single day. It may be a tremendous hardship to include classic ice cream into a diet, and the majority of people aren’t pleased with the minuscule portion sizes that are necessary.
In the course of our search for the finest coffee ice cream, we were astonished and overjoyed to discover that there are various selections that are compatible with keto and low-carb diets. These ice creams will satisfy your want for a sweet treat while also ensuring that you don’t use up all of your remaining calorie allowance for the day.
To increase the degree of pleasure even further, one of our favourite strategies is to choose ice cream that is loaded with something crunchy. This brings the total amount of satisfaction to an all-time high. Chocolate chips, chocolate chunks, and espresso beans all contribute significantly to our delight while contributing very little additional calories.
- Artificial Sweeteners
The use of artificial sweeteners is a subject that is connected to diet. Because artificial sweeteners are used in the majority of low-sugar alternatives, you should take care to choose an ice cream that does not include sucralose or aspartame in its ingredients. There are alternatives that are better for you that don’t have any unpleasant aftertastes but yet provide the same level of satisfaction while having less sugar.
Allulose is a natural sweetener that may be used in place of sugar in a variety of applications without altering the taste of the dish or beverage to which it is added. Because there are other sugar substitutes that are available at a lower cost, the price of an ice cream with a lower total amount of sugar that is of a good quality will be more. Despite this, it is definitely worthwhile if only for the sake of great ice cream and improved health.
- Toppings
There are as many different tastes for ice cream toppings as there are individuals. When compiling this list of ice cream flavours, we came to the conclusion that coffee should take centre stage, and that any toppings should be chosen with the intention of enhancing the coffee flavour. The most apparent option is chocolate, but you shouldn’t rule out more unusual tastes like chicory just because they’re unique. Chocolate is always a safe bet. There are times when seemingly unlikely taste combinations might come together to create a delectable confection.
If you only want an ice cream with a coffee taste, then the strength of the coffee flavour in the ice cream should be your first priority. You should search for ice cream that is produced with genuine coffee regardless of whether or not there are toppings added, but it is much more important for plain coffee ice cream to have actual coffee as an ingredient.
A excellent black coffee with no additives. Additionally, ice cream makes for an excellent foundation upon which one may build their own toppings at home. The addition of raspberries and blueberries brings a new dimension of taste to the blend, one that is reminiscent of some fruity coffees. When we are in the mood for a dessert that is inspired by lattes, we also prefer to use cinnamon in the recipe.
- Price
The cost is the very last thing to think about. In general, low-cost coffee ice cream is manufactured using artificial flavours, artificial sweeteners, and ice cream of a lower quality. Even though it seems like a good deal at the time, it is best to spend a little bit more money on authentic coffee ice cream that is manufactured with either sugar or a sugar replacement that is healthier for your health. Although this does not imply that you have to spend an exorbitant amount of money, it is probable that you will be dissatisfied if you pay the lowest possible price.
If you want to save more of your hard-earned cash in your pocket, you might think about getting a coffee ice cream that does not include any additional flavours or toppings. Purchasing basic ice cream and then embellishing it with chocolate chips or other toppings after the fact is the more economical option. This also gives you the freedom to customise your dessert and put your own unique spin on it, which is a great benefit.
Conclusion
Coffee and ice cream are two dessert favourites that, when combined, form a traditional duo that is, in some mysterious way, even better. We don’t know many people who don’t like coffee ice cream, and when we buy it for our refrigerator, it doesn’t stick around for long. We bit the bullet and made the ultimate sacrifice in order to offer you these in-depth assessments by subjecting ourselves to the arduous task of tasting coffee ice cream.
Our top overall recommendation is Ben & Jerry’s “Coffee, Coffee BuzzBuzzBuzz!” for a traditional ice cream that is absolutely overflowing with coffee flavor. The chocolate chunks also add a great texture and flavor to the mix.
If you’re looking to save some money, look no further than Häagen-Dazs Coffee ice cream. It’s a tasty wallet-friendly option but is also great if you want a no-frills coffee ice cream. On the other hand, for a bit more money, you can get a too-good-to-be-true healthier option from Sweetie. Their ice cream is delicious, but also low on fat and sugar. We’re willing to bet you wouldn’t know it was low fat if we didn’t tell you.
We’re satisfied with our list and hope it helps you decide which coffee ice cream is right for you. But maybe we should try just a few more – you know, for science.
Like This? Check Out More Coffee Food Recipes